Today, we will be looking at the best hospitals in Indianapolis. According to the 2018 America’s Health Rankings report, Indianapolis ranks 41st in the nation in overall health and 42nd in mental health, according to Mental Health in America 2019.
In Indianapolis, one baby dies every 14 hours, amounting to 600 infant deaths per year, making the state’s infant mortality rate one of the highest in the country.
Indianapolis also has one of the top ten highest cancer death rates in the country.
The history of hospitals in Indianapolis
Throughout much of the nineteenth century, hospitals provided few benefits to the sick and suffering.
The majority of patients were treated in their own homes by doctors. Early hospitals were little more than welfare institutions, having evolved from almshouses.
At the time, medical care was scarce in these institutions, and infection-related deaths were common (approximately 10 percent).
Patients in these early hospitals were impoverished and had been abandoned by their families and friends.
By the mid-nineteenth century, the majority of municipal hospitals had abandoned their welfare functions and began operating as true hospitals, providing primary medical care to the poor. A number of private or volunteer hospitals also serve the poor.
Related: Best hospitals in El Paso
The middle class did not use hospital facilities until the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. During the Civil War, Indianapolis opened its first hospital. The federal government used the Indianapolis City Hospital (now Wishard Memorial Hospital) to care for sick and injured soldiers.
Following the war, the city took over control of the facility and ran it as a charity hospital for the poor. The hospital, like many others in the city, was constantly overcrowded and chronically underfunded.
The late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries saw the expansion of City Hospital and the establishment of a number of other hospitals to provide better care for both the deserving poor and paying patients. The St. Vincent Infirmary (later St. Vincent Hospital) was founded in 1881 by the Daughters of Charity of the St. Vincent de Paul Society. The Protestant Deaconess Hospital and Home for the Aged (later known as the Indiana Christian Hospital and Clinic) first opened its doors in 1899.
In 1908, the Epworth League dedicated its 65-bed Methodist Episcopal Hospital (now known as Methodist Hospital).
See Also; Best eye hospitals in New York
Despite the fact that all of these institutions initially accepted charity cases, the majority of patients paid for care, and as a result, the care at these institutions was superior to that at City Hospital.
These new hospitals and hospital additions used cutting-edge hospital architecture techniques. Most were designed in a pavilion style, which maximized ventilation, reduced ward crowding, and reduced the risk of infection. Pavilion hospitals were typically large, one- or two-story structures.
By the early twentieth century, much of the stigma associated with hospitals had faded. Hospitals began to offer specialty services such as infectious disease care, obstetrics and gynecology, ophthalmology, gastroenterology, neurology, and urology.
Hospitals were also influenced by the tremendous growth of medical science and technology (particularly the development of germ theory and bacteriology), improvements in medical education, and the professionalization of nursing.
For the first time, hospitals had the potential to provide superior care to that available at home. They also became an important part of the medical education system, as well as important training facilities for medical students and nurses, as well as major research facilities.
Hospital consolidation and a building boom have increased utilization and prices.
Observers in the Indianapolis health care market pointed to two major factors driving up costs: horizontal and vertical consolidation among the four major hospital systems, as well as a recent building spree in the more affluent Indianapolis suburbs.
The systems’ acquisitions of other Indiana hospitals outside the metropolitan region were strategic, according to one observer, who noted that “communities where there was a [hospital] monopoly” were targeted and then used to negotiate “tying contracts” with payers, which meant that payers wishing to contract with the “must have” hospital in one community were required to include all hospitals in the system in their networks.
According to one employer representative, there is no “value competition” in the Indianapolis market because the four hospital systems have a “pretty broad” reach.
The acquisition of physician groups by hospitals has also increased costs, though not entirely due to higher prices.
Respondents report that, despite hospital systems’ attempts to demand higher reimbursement for physician services, payers were able to maintain their fee schedules largely unchanged.
However, the purchase of other service providers by hospitals, such as labs and imaging centers, has resulted in price inflation.
One stakeholder discovered that when a hospital acquires a sleep lab, “you’re immediately [paying] the hospital’s negotiated rate, which is typically higher than when it was the independent provider.”
Furthermore, costs have risen because acquired physicians are now referring patients within their health system rather than to the lowest-cost provider.
As a result, rather than referring a patient to a lower-cost free-standing MRI facility, hospital-employed physicians refer the patient within the hospital system, even if the MRI is 40% more expensive.
To generate more revenue, hospital systems have also used “facility fees,” in which payers are charged an additional fee for services provided in a hospital-owned clinic.
According to one observer, hospitals saw “a lot of money to be made [having] physicians under the hospital’s roof.” Others noted that insurers fought the facility fees at first, but “didn’t have anything to push back with,” and eventually caved.
The hospital construction boom in the Indianapolis suburbs has, somewhat counterintuitively, pushed up prices. “Competition was supposed to keep prices down, and that’s not happening,” one large local employer said.
Others noted that the construction initially increased utilization due to a “overcapacity of beds” and aggressive marketing efforts by hospitals. The increase in utilization has leveled off in recent years, but hospitals have increased their unit prices “dramatically,” according to one purchaser.
Experts went on to explain that existing hospitals that faced new competition frequently raised prices for commercially insured patients to compensate for the loss of inpatient revenue. Because of increased competition, existing hospitals had fewer patients but the same overhead. Hospitals must raise their prices in order to remain financially viable.
Best hospitals in Indianapolis
We compiled this list of top hospitals in Indianapolis using data from reputable sources such as Medicare and U.S. News & World Report.
- Ascension St. Vincent Evansville Hospital
Address: 3700 Washington Ave, Evansville, IN 47714, United States
Website: Click here
Phone: +1 812-485-4000
U.S. News & World Report ranks St. Vincent Evansville high in heart attack, heart failure, kidney failure, and knee replacement.
The Level II Trauma Care hospital is part of the St. Vincent Health System hospitals, Indiana’s largest healthcare system, and an Ascension Health member. The facility received the Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award two years in a row, in 2021 and 2022, as well as a four-star rating from the federal government.
- Deaconess Midtown Hospital
Address: 600 Mary St, Evansville, IN 47710, United States
Phone: +1 812-450-5000
Website: Click here
U.S. News & World Report ranked Deaconess Midtown Hospital No. 2 in Indiana and rated high performing in several procedures or conditions, including colon cancer surgery and heart attack.
Healthgrades awarded the organization America’s 250 Best Hospitals Award in 2022, The Leapfrog Group an “A” grade in 2021 for its excellence in hospital safety, and the federal government a three-star rating.
- Good Samaritan Hospital
Website: Click here
Address: 520 S. Seventh St. Vincennes, IN 47591
Good Samaritan Hospital is part of the region’s leading health system in southwestern Indiana and southeastern Illinois.
In 2021, the organization received several awards, including the Joint Commission National Quality Approval Award and the American Heart Association’s Gold Plus Get With The Guidelines-Stroke Quality Achievement Award.
It was also named an INspire Hospital of Distinction for Infant and Maternal Health Excellence. The federal government has given it a three-star rating.
- Indiana University Health Ball Memorial Hospital
Address: 2401 W University Ave, Muncie, IN 47303, United States
Phone: +1 765-747-3111
Affiliated university: Indiana University
Website: Click here
U.S. News & World Report ranks IU Health Ball Memorial Hospital as the fourth best hospital in Indiana, with high ratings for heart attacks, kidney failure, and four other procedures or conditions.
The ANCC awarded the academic teaching hospital the Pathway to Excellence Designation for its positive environment for nurses looking to advance their careers.
In 2022, it received the Healthgrades Patient Safety Excellence Award, as well as the Blue Distinction (in cardiac care, maternity care, and orthopedic care) from Blue Cross Blue Shield.
Ball Memorial Hospital is Muncie’s only hospital and is rated three stars by the federal government. In addition, its health-care system, Indiana Health, is the largest in the state.
- Parkview Regional Medical Center
Address: 11109 Parkview Plaza Dr Entrance 1, Fort Wayne, IN 46845, United States
Phone: +1 260-266-1000
Website: Click here
U.S. News & World Report ranks Parkview Regional Medical Center fourth in Indiana and high performing in several procedures or conditions, including colon cancer surgery and heart attack.
The ANCC accredited its nurse residency program through the Practice Transition Accreditation Program in 2020, and the hospital received an “A” grade from The Leapfrog Group for its efforts in hospital safety.
Also, the facility was also accredited by the American College of Surgeons (ACS) and the American Society for Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery’s Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery Accreditation and Quality Improvement Program (ASMBS). The federal government has given the facility a three-star rating.
- St Mary’s Medical Center
Address: 1500 S Lake Park Ave, Hobart, IN 46342, United States
Website: Click here
Phone: +1 219-942-0551
St. Mary Medical Center is a leading provider of expert medical care to residents of Northwest Indiana by investing in new technologies and cutting-edge treatments.
For increased collaboration and accountability in patient care, the hospital also employs multidisciplinary teams of health professionals and shared governance among nursing staff.
Several quality awards and accreditations have resulted from these efforts, recognizing St. Mary Medical Center’s consistent excellence in health outcomes and patient experience.
Among the hospital’s accomplishments are:
A Surgical Pavilion and ICU expansion worth $40 million
Acquisition of the TrueBeam system – a revolutionary image-guided radiotherapy system that is now part of our nationally accredited cancer care program
Award-winning Joint Academy – orthopedic surgery program with some of the best outcomes in the country
High-Risk Breast Clinic – Personalized care for women at high risk of breast cancer.
Commitment to community outreach through collaborations with local YMCAs and the Brickie Clinic
Anticoagulation Clinic – management of patients taking blood clot prevention or treatment medications.
- Franciscan St Francis Health – Indianapolis
Address: 8111 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46237, United States
Phone: +1 317-528-5000
Website: Click here
Franciscan Health Indianapolis has the only full-service heart and vascular care program on Indianapolis’ south side.
Truven Health Analytics named our Indianapolis hospital, located just north of Greenwood, one of the top 100 hospitals in the United States.
- Columbus Regional Hospital
Address: 2400 17th St, Columbus, IN 47201, United States
Phone: +1 800-841-4938
For the past 100 years, Columbus Regional Health has touched, saved, and improved the lives of people in our community.
Our team provides world-class care and services in order to be your long-term health and wellness partner.
- Adams Memorial Hospital
Address: 1100 Mercer Ave, Decatur, IN 46733, United States
Website: Click here
Phone: +1 260-724-2145
Adams County Memorial Hospital in Decatur, Indiana, provides high-quality, comprehensive care with cutting-edge treatment options and open access to all.
We are always adding new services and developing new specialties. OB-GYN, orthopedics, pediatrics, interventional spine and pain management, regenerative medicine, neurology, internal medicine, weight management, pulmonology, and sleep medicine are just a few of the new specialty services we’ve added in recent years.
- Bluffton Regional Medical Center
Address: 303 S Main St, Bluffton, IN 46714, United States
Website: Click here
Phone: +1 260-824-3210
Bluffton Regional Medical Center has 79 beds and offers inpatient, outpatient, diagnostic imaging, medical, surgical, women’s services, and emergency care.
We are committed to providing compassionate, quality care with the best possible experience to every patient, every time, and to make a positive impact on our community. We are accredited by The Joint Commission and a proud member of the Lutheran Health Network.
FAQs about the best hospitals in Indianapolis
- What is the name of Indianapolis’ largest hospital?
Indiana University Health Methodist Hospital is a hospital affiliated with Indiana University Health, located in Indianapolis, Indiana, USA. It is Indiana’s largest hospital and one of only four regional Level I Trauma Centers in the state.
- In Indiana, how many Level 1 trauma centers are there?
According to the Indiana State Department of Health, Indiana has only six Level 2 trauma centers. Level 1 ERs provide the most advanced trauma care.
According to the Indiana State Department of Health, the state has only four verified Level 1 trauma centers.
- Which hospitals in Indianapolis are the best?
The Indiana University Health Medical Center in Indianapolis is the top hospital in Indiana.
Hoosier hospitals ranked among the best Anderson and Madison County Community Hospitals (tied, 4th) Mishawaka Medical Center, Franciscan Health Indianapolis (tied for fourth place).
- Where does Indiana stand in terms of health care?
According to the 2018 America’s Health Rankings report, Indiana ranks 41st in the nation in overall health and 42nd in mental health, according to Mental Health in America 2019.
A final thought on the best hospitals in Indianapolis
Choosing the best hospital necessitates a thorough examination of the costs and efficiency of care, both of which are critical to patients.
This article discussed some of the best hospitals in Indianapolis, ranked based on their performance, which is weighted far more heavily than the other factors. We hope this helps you.